Babu Owino’s ally Kivutha Kibwana exposed as X influencer Hannes Bend revisits Makueni scandals

Former Makueni Governor Kivutha Kibwana has come under renewed scrutiny after X influencer Hannes Bend revisited a series of controversies surrounding his tenure, raising questions about public expenditure, stalled development projects and the appointment of his brother to a senior county position.

In a post, Bend described Kibwana as an intellectual whose public profile and leadership positions helped create credibility, while questioning whether his administration’s record matched the reputation he enjoyed.

The post revisited several issues that had previously attracted the attention of Parliament, the Auditor-General and anti-corruption investigators during Kibwana’s tenure.

Among the issues raised was the appointment of Kibwana’s brother, Patrick Musyoki Kibwana, as Makueni County’s Health Chief Officer.

In May 2021, Kibwana appeared before the Senate Health Committee, where legislators questioned the potential conflict of interest arising from his brother’s position.

The former governor maintained that he did not participate in the recruitment, arguing that the County Public Service Board handled the process and forwarded the successful candidate’s name to the County Assembly for approval.

Senators, however, questioned the circumstances surrounding the appointment and the brother’s involvement in managing health workers.

Embakasi East Babu Owino speaks to the media. PHOTO/https://web.facebook.com/babuowinongili

KSh29.7 million dam payment raises questions

Another issue highlighted by Bend concerns the KSh29.71 million Makueni County paid towards the rehabilitation of Kamunyolo Water Earth Dam.

According to the Auditor-General’s report for the 2020/2021 financial year, the project was supposed to be completed within 90 days, with the deadline falling on June 18, 2020.

However, a physical inspection conducted in November 2021 established that the project had stalled.

The auditor questioned the regularity, completeness and value for money of the KSh29,714,356 expenditure, saying the available records could not confirm whether taxpayers received value for the money spent.

The audit also identified a discrepancy involving KSh803.26 million recorded as transfers to other government units.

While Makueni’s financial statements reflected the expenditure, the Integrated Financial Management Information System (IFMIS) showed zero spending under the same category.

The auditor said the difference had not been explained or reconciled, making it impossible to confirm the accuracy and completeness of the expenditure.

Former Makueni Governor Kivutha Kibwana during a past event. PHOTO/Screengrab

Senate raised questions over KSh1.4 billion projects

Kibwana’s administration had also faced scrutiny over a dossier presented to the Senate in September 2019, outlining allegations involving 12 county projects valued at approximately KSh1.4 billion.

The Senate County Public Accounts and Investments Committee referred the matter to the Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC) for investigation.

Among the issues raised was an alleged payment of approximately KSh4 million to Shina Foundation, associated with Kibwana’s wife, Nazi Kivutha.

Kibwana disputed the claims and asked the committee to invite his wife to respond to the allegations.

The Star+2

Separately, the Auditor-General flagged 26 Makueni development projects valued at approximately KSh146 million that had either stalled or failed to start during the 2017/2018 financial year.

Kibwana defended his administration, citing challenges including inadequate funding, land problems and changes requested by residents.

The Senate committee questioned the quality of the audit information and demanded further clarification on the projects’ status.

The renewed scrutiny comes as questions emerge over the difference between Kibwana’s public reputation and the financial accountability issues recorded during his administration.

Related posts

Temperatures rise as Muturi, Kalonzo issue joint demand to IEBC months before 2027 poll

Gladys Wanga beats Ann Waiguru in most influential woman leader poll, Mwelekeo Insights

Edwin Sifuna (25.1%) leads Ruto (13.4%), Matiang’i (12.6%) and Kalonzo (12.5%) in Mwelekeo Insights poll.